A Comprehensive Guide to Environmental Compliance in California (CEQA 2023)

Introduction

The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) has long served as a cornerstone of environmental compliance and regulation in California. For decades, it has ensured that government agencies thoroughly assess and disclose the environmental impacts of development projects before granting approvals.

The CEQA Handbook 2023 offers the latest updates to statutory requirements, procedural refinements, and legal interpretations—reinforcing how California continues to lead in environmental review standards.

This guide provides a comprehensive overview of the key components outlined in the 2023 CEQA Handbook, including critical legal precedents, required environmental documentation, agency responsibilities, and how all stakeholders—from city planners and environmental consultants to private developers—can navigate the CEQA review process with confidence and legal compliance.

What Is CEQA?

The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), enacted in 1970, requires that state and local agencies evaluate environmental impacts before approving any public or private development projects.

CEQA’s central goals are to:

• Disclose environmental impacts of proposed actions
• Avoid or reduce those impacts through feasible alternatives or CEQA mitigation measures
• Foster public participation in the environmental decision-making process
  

The 2023 CEQA Handbook reinforces CEQA’s original mission—not just to document potential impacts but to encourage sustainable, environmentally responsible planning at every project stage.

For guidance on regulatory engineering and compliance, explore our Power System Studies or Substation Design Services.

CEQA’s Three-Tiered Review Process

Under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), the environmental review process is structured into three main levels depending on the potential environmental impact of a project:

a. CEQA Exemptions

Certain projects are statutorily or categorically exempt from CEQA review. Common examples include:

• Ministerial projects (e.g., business license issuance)
• Emergency repairs to public infrastructure
• Small-scale infill development in urbanized areas

These CEQA exemptions are designed to streamline approvals for low-impact or routine activities.

b. Initial Study (IS)

When a project is not exempt, an Initial Study (IS) is conducted to evaluate potential environmental impacts. Based on findings, the agency may issue:

• A Negative Declaration (ND) if no significant environmental effects are anticipated.
• A Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) if impacts are identified but can be reduced through feasible mitigation measures.

This tier ensures responsible planning without the need for a full EIR if impacts can be controlled.

c. Environmental Impact Report (EIR)

If the Initial Study identifies potentially significant impacts, a comprehensive Environmental Impact Report (EIR) is required. The EIR is CEQA’s most detailed and rigorous document and must include:

• A complete project description
  
• An assessment of the environmental baseline
  
• Impact analysis across various categories
  
• Evaluation of project alternatives
  
• Clearly defined mitigation strategies

Learn how we support developers with regulatory studies by exploring our NERC Compliance Services or POI Interconnection Engineering Support.

Lead, Responsible, and Trustee Agencies

The 2023 CEQA Handbook emphasizes the importance of clearly identifying the roles of all involved government entities in the CEQA environmental review process:

• Lead Agency: Oversees CEQA compliance and is responsible for preparing environmental documents (e.g., EIRs or MNDs).
• Responsible Agency: Approves or funds a portion of the project but does not lead the environmental review.
• Trustee Agency: Holds jurisdiction over resources potentially affected by the project (e.g., the California Department of Fish & Wildlife).
  

Accurate designation of these agencies is essential to maintain procedural compliance, prevent delays, and ensure a coordinated environmental impact assessment.

Determining Project Significance

Determining environmental significance is a critical component of CEQA compliance. The evaluation considers several key factors:

• Context: Whether the project is in an urban or rural setting, and the scope and scale of its impacts.
• Thresholds of Significance: These thresholds—often established by state or local regulatory standards, such as GHG emission limits set by the California Air Resources Board—help identify when an impact is considered significant.
• Cumulative Impacts: CEQA requires consideration of a project’s combined environmental impacts with past, present, or foreseeable future projects.
  

To guide this process, Appendix G of the CEQA Guidelines provides a standardized environmental checklist for evaluating significance across various categories such as air quality, noise, traffic, and more.

2023 Legal Cases Shaping CEQA

The 2023 CEQA Handbook outlines key court decisions from 2022 that significantly influence how CEQA regulations are interpreted and enforced:

• G.I. Industries v. City of Thousand Oaks: Clarified the evaluation of waste disposal impacts under CEQA.
  
• County of Butte v. Dept. of Water Resources: Addressed the adequacy of environmental baseline data used in EIRs.
  
• Southwest Regional Council of Carpenters v. City of Los Angeles: Reaffirmed the importance of a thorough cumulative impact assessment.
  

These cases highlight the legal expectation for accurate, defensible environmental documentation and reinforce the need for a strong administrative record throughout the CEQA process.

The Role of Public Participation 

Public participation in CEQA is a foundational requirement, ensuring transparency and accountability in the environmental review process. CEQA mandates robust engagement through:

• Public scoping meetings to identify environmental issues early
• Written public comments on Draft Environmental Impact Reports (EIRs)
• Formal responses to comments in Final EIRs
  

Government agencies must demonstrate that they have considered and addressed public concerns, a common focal point in CEQA-related litigation.

For projects involving public infrastructure or energy development, Keentel provides Owner’s Engineer Services to support stakeholder coordination and regulatory alignment.

Mitigation, Monitoring, and Reporting

CEQA requires all environmental mitigation measures to be:

• Feasible within the project’s scope and budget
• Clearly defined in writing
• Legally enforceable by the reviewing agency
  

For any project with an EIR or Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND), a Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP) is mandatory. This program ensures that all mitigation actions are implemented and tracked throughout the project lifecycle.

CEQA vs. NEPA: Understanding the Differences

When a project involves federal funding or approval, both CEQA and NEPA compliance may be required. Here's how they differ:

The 2023 CEQA Handbook encourages joint CEQA–NEPA document preparation where applicable, helping streamline reviews and reduce redundancy in environmental assessments.

Programmatic vs. Project-Level Review 

CEQA distinguishes between two core environmental review types:

• Program EIRs: Broad environmental documents used for overarching policies, agency programs, or regional development plans.
  
• Project EIRs: Site-specific reports focused on the environmental impacts of a single, defined development.
  

The 2023 CEQA Handbook supports the principle of CEQA tiering, where detailed project-level analyses build upon prior programmatic environmental reviews. This layered approach enhances efficiency and reduces duplication in California environmental compliance.

CEQA Streamlining and SB 35

To encourage sustainable development and affordable housing in California, CEQA offers streamlining provisions for qualifying projects. These include:

• Infill development exemptions for small-scale urban projects
• SB 35 ministerial approval pathways for housing that meets affordability and zoning criteria
• CEQA Guidelines §15183, which allows exemptions for projects consistent with a certified General Plan EIR
  

Such CEQA streamlining tools accelerate project approvals while maintaining environmental due diligence.

Climate Change and CEQA

Addressing climate change impacts under CEQA remains a top regulatory priority. Agencies must:

• Quantify greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions using accepted models like CalEEMod
• Compare emissions against local or state GHG thresholds of significance
• Demonstrate consistency with adopted GHG reduction plans or climate action strategies
  

The 2023 CEQA Handbook reinforces the need for projects to provide defensible GHG analysis in all applicable environmental impact reports.

Technical Appendices: Appendix G and Beyond

To support accurate environmental assessments, the handbook includes updated versions of:

• Appendix G: Comprehensive CEQA Initial Study Checklist
• Appendix F: Guidelines for Energy Consumption Analysis
• Appendix D: Emissions criteria for GHG impact assessments
  

These appendices are critical tools for CEQA consultants, engineers, and environmental planners conducting technical analysis and documentation.

CEQA Challenges and Litigation

Common CEQA legal challenges involve allegations of:

• Inadequate environmental impact analysis
• Failure to adopt feasible mitigation measures
• Insufficient public notification or access to documents
  

To mitigate CEQA litigation risks, agencies must maintain comprehensive administrative records and provide timely, detailed responses to public comments throughout the EIR process.

Electronic and Digital Tools

The 2023 CEQA Handbook emphasizes the integration of digital tools in environmental review to enhance transparency and stakeholder participation. It promotes the use of:

• Online public notices for broader access and visibility
• Digital scoping materials that allow efficient document circulation
• Interactive EIR platforms to facilitate dynamic, user-friendly navigation of large environmental reports

These innovations support modern CEQA compliance by making the process more transparent, efficient, and accessible to the public and agencies alike.

CEQA Training and Certification 

To ensure consistent, legally sound CEQA documentation, professional training is essential. Organizations such as the Association of Environmental Professionals (AEP) and affiliated institutions offer:

• CEQA certification programs
  
• Legal compliance workshops
  
• Specialized training for consultants and agency staff

These programs help build technical expertise and ensure agencies stay aligned with current CEQA regulations, legal precedents, and best practices in environmental impact reporting.

Frequently Asked Questions

Conclusion

The 2023 CEQA Handbook marks a significant step forward in how California approaches environmental review. With updated procedures, clarified legal interpretations, and the promotion of digital compliance tools, the new guidelines aim to streamline approvals without compromising ecological responsibility.

For city planners, developers, environmental consultants, and public agencies, understanding CEQA is not just a legal necessity—it’s a pathway to responsible, resilient development. Mastering its tiers, thresholds, and documentation requirements ensures your projects remain compliant, defensible, and community-conscious.

Need Expert Support with CEQA Compliance or Environmental Engineering?

Our team of licensed engineers and regulatory experts is ready to help you navigate complex compliance landscapes—accurately, efficiently, and on deadline.

Contact Us Today to schedule a consultation or explore our full range of NERC Compliance Services.